(Archive) Advertising District / Disneyland Park
- 02-May 04
-
Geoff Offline
Wow, this is by far one of the best updates of this park.
Everything here is so well done. The first screen is just beautiful. All that brown, and the windows, it just clearly brings out the theme.
The tree's trunk I think needs a bit of work. But the greenery on it are fantastic! The walk-ways on the trunk, just don't look detailed enough. -
JKay Offline
Best update yet Ice. Really incredible stuff here. My favorite are the first and fourth screen. I think what I like the most is how you took normally crappy RCT2 custom foliage objects and have managed to place them in an organized, artistic way to create the Disney beauty you are so good at. Just amazing man, seriously. In my eyes, you and DisneyFreak are by far the best active Disney RCT2'ers atm. -
Richie Offline
Im going to pick holes.
The yellow line points out landscaping, that whole edge is perfectly lined up, looks poor. It doesnt need a lot, just some sort of change.
2 green circles, the highest one, looks like the water is going to over flow, try raising it a bit. The lower green circle points out a mistake i see in soo many parks, really annoying too The water is flowing against an invisible ledge.
Red = missing pieces? I just thought i would point that out incase.
Black circles are say ugly custom scenery. Mainly the rocks, although i dont really like the trees much either. I know your not going to change them, its just personal preference.
Also, you could try the ice walls behind the waterfall, it gives it more depth IMO, some people will dissagree i know, but at the moment it looks kinda bar, like its a single line of water.
Its all picky little things, but i thought that would be better than another "Ah it looks great, keep up the good work!! " -
postit Offline
I agree with everything that Richie said about that screen except the custom scenery. I think that if you zero clearance absolute over the rock in the water, it will look a lot better. But this is all still really amazing. -
Sparker9014 Offline
i to wana be an imageineer but no high school course for so i bought the cad system good luck with this project -
Sparker9014 Offline
one more thing for the hub and freinds on main street its got all the disney characters lined up around the big cheese and mickey. if you could add em in it would look preety good -
The Rick 5 Offline
This is really just nitpicking but in the tiki room screen, the tall pagoda looks bare. IMO it really looks like you should be able to see supports in between the roof sections. Im not sure what but something. Just my two cents so take it as you will.
The Rick -
JKay Offline
Honestly, it'd be nice if you could back up such a harsh opinion with some fucking insight....fuck-an-A mayneI think it looks like shit, honestly.
All I know is that this park kick major Disney ass. Richie made some really good points about that one screen tho. -
Highball Offline
Mind telling me why you think it looks like shit?I think it looks like shit, honestly.
And Richie, thanks for the tips. I know the waterfall sucks and I'll address that before the release. Right now though I'm watching the map data limit very carefully so I tried not to overdo the waterfall.
JKay, thanks for the very kind comments. Too bad Walt Mart is in limbo right now... I was really looking foward to your Main Street. -
cg? Offline
"Pleasure" and "displeasure" are emotions, emotions follow no logical set of rules or guidelines, and to try and explain or debate them using logic is pointless.
All I can say is that I find your screenshots displeasurable to look at. If I could elaborate, I would. -
Turtle Offline
I don't think it's especially helpful to post displaying your "displeasure", as you so succinctly put it. There really was nothing to be gained from doing it, by either party. -
Highball Offline
What the hell? How can you not know what bothers you?"Pleasure" and "displeasure" are emotions, emotions follow no logical set of rules or guidelines, and to try and explain or debate them using logic is pointless.
All I can say is that I find your screenshots displeasurable to look at. If I could elaborate, I would. -
Panic Offline
Because CG's default outlook on screens is negative or seems so, and when it is that so continuously it begins to become automatic and he doesn't need a reason anymore. -
spiderman Offline
I think it looks alright. The hideous selection of trees that you used combined perfectly to form a rather pleasant jungle feel. The architecture is decent, nothing amazing, but a good atmosphere makes up for that. I like it, keep up the good work. -
cg? Offline
Well people have posted here, and in other topics, things like "oh, wow, that's wonderful!", and nobody minds, so why can't I posted "oh, wow, that's shit", if that's how I feel?I don't think it's especially helpful to post displaying your "displeasure", as you so succinctly put it. There really was nothing to be gained from doing it, by either party.
Seems a bit silly.What the hell? How can you not know what bothers you?
If it was a "flawed" work then pinpointing the flaws would be easy. But it isn't a "flawed" work, it is a "shit" work, meaning, that, well, I don't like any of it! -
X250 Offline
How can you say this work is shit? You know it is good work, in fact it is some of the best work i have ever seen. You just want to be different for the sake of being different- if you think this is shit than i suppose it is your opinion. I am just telling you that your opinion is wrong.
I think it is wonderful work Iceman, just keep it up.
-X- -
Sparker9014 Offline
if you dont like it dont look at it dont post somthin . if you wanna be a critic tell him somthing to help out not be a shit about it and say its shit. -
cg? Offline
The only wrong opinions are those which contradict mine! So, I'm afraid, your opinion is wrong.How can you say this work is shit? You know it is good work, in fact it is some of the best work i have ever seen. You just want to be different for the sake of being different- if you think this is shit than i suppose it is your opinion. I am just telling you that your opinion is wrong.
if you dont like it dont look at it dont post somthin . if you wanna be a critic tell him somthing to help out not be a shit about it and say its shit.
Again, this time in bold: People have posted here, and in other topics, things like "oh, wow, that's wonderful!", and nobody minds, so why can't I post "oh, wow, that's shit", if that's how I feel?
Seems a bit silly.
Tags
- No Tags