H2H8/8 / Rank the H2H8/8 Parks!

  • Ling%s's Photo

    This seems to be an H2H tradition, after all, and now that all of the parks are in (and quite a few have accolades) I thought it'd be fun to see how people rank all 20 parks (or just a top 10).

     

    R1M1 - fLLorists - Subdued Thought

    R1M1 - TropicaLL Storms - Parco Romania

    R1M2 - ][LLuminati - Firestorm

    R1M2 - Lisa & the Domain Names - Beachcomber Cove

    R2M1 - LLawbreakers - MS Office Suite 2003 Resort

    R2M1 - fLLorists - Morthal

    R2M2 - ][LLuminati - Hidden Kingdom

    R2M2 - LLawbreakers - Futuropolis

    R2M3 - LLawbreakers - Hitchhikers Harbor

    R2M3 - TropicaLL Storms - Isla del Tesoro Perdido

    R3M1 - Lisa & the Domain Names - Valle Del Amanecer

    R3M1 - LLawbreakers - Celtic Legends

    R4M1 - Lisa & the Domain Names - Mount Playstack

    R4M1 - TropicaLL Storms - Blizzard Bay

    R4M2 - LLawbreakers - Astroworld

    R4M2 - ][LLuminati - Learnatorium: Age of Dinos

    R5M1 - TropicaLL Storms - Mongo Tropica

    R5M1 - fLLorists - Emerald Heights

    R5M2 - TropicaLL Storms - Toreador

    R5M2 - ][LLuminati - Rot

  • G Force%s's Photo

    Top 10 for me would probably be:

    Mongo Tropica (lol)

    MS Office Suite

    Learnatorium

    Valle Del Amanecer

    Blizzard Bay

    Toreador

    Emerald Heights

    Beachcomber Cove

    Hidden Kingdom

    Celtic Legends

     

    Lots of quality parks, definitely increased as the contest wore on.  Not sure if there any "classics" by the normal definition but certainly some great parkmaking and a number of new LL builders showcasing some great potential.

  • Cocoa%s's Photo

    how do we have a 50% win rate with three parks

  • Ling%s's Photo

    For some reason I thought TropicaLL Storms and Lisa & the Domain Names each had four parks (didn't read my own damn list), not 5 and 3 respectively. TropicaLL Storms were at 50% with R5M1, assuming an extra 10+ votes don't flood in.

     

    If TropicaLL Storms win R5M2, they take the contest with 3 wins, but Lisa & the Domain Names score a higher win rate at 67%. If ][LLumanti win, we take the contest also with 3 wins, but also in percentage at 75%. It's kind of weird because the total number of parks is so low.

     

    I think it will be interesting to see how people rank the parks. Most of the strong parks ended up against other strong parks, so the win rates aren't really reflective of total team quality.

  • Jaguar%s's Photo

    Okay, this thread deserves more action, so here's my unbiased™ ranking:

     

     

    1. Mongo Tropica - Talk about annihilation with misplaced competitiveness... amazing though

    2. Celtic Legends - Okay, I'm biased but this was a pain in the ass to make, okay?

    3. Valle Del Amanecer - Serious now... possibly the best composition seen in the contest

    4. MS Office Suite 2003 Resort - One of the best, most nostalgic ideas of the contest, except clippy

    5. Toreador - Feels like Valle Del Amanecer... good composition too

    6. Astroworld - Really cool... too much goo but the theme was well executed and lol at Posix

    7. Learnatorium: Age of Dinos - Nicely done but messy and archaeology is not paleontology, dammit!

    8. Hidden Kingdom - Great atmosphere, nice architecture, and an excellent layout

    9. Futuropolis - Really messy but cool theme with two awesome coasters

    10. Emerald Heights - I thought the composition in this one was great, very clean

    11. Blizzard Bay - An exceptional winter park with good landscaping and lots of snowmen

    12. Rot - Wit's End Jr. pretty much, the giant shroom is cool... wish it had a readme

    13. Beachcomber Cove - Good old realism, nicely executed, not much to complain about

    14. Mount Playstack - Fun, old school, saccharine Christmas stuff

    15. Isla del Tesoro Perdido - A nice park made all the more impressive with no hacks

    16. Subdued Thought - Certainly controversial... this is either surreal genius or a complete mess

    17. Firestorm - Colorful, open but bare, and I'm glad someone used the lava palette

    18. Hitchhikers Harbor - A nice little park, very basic but unpretentious

    19. Morthal - This one had cool ideas like the candy rocks but the foliage was way too bare imo

    20. Parco Romania - Not terrible, just not all that interesting

  • Cocoa%s's Photo

    Ms Office Suite

    Toreador

    Valle Del Amanecer

    Astroworld

    Futuropolis 

     

    thats probably my top 5

  • Ling%s's Photo

    I'm going to do a few different lists. These aren't strictly in order.

     

    Top 5 favorite for most effort/best execution:

    Mongo Tropica

    Celtic Legends

    MS Office Suite

    Toreador

    Astroworld

     

    Top 5 most in the spirit of the contest:

    Emerald Heights

    Learnatorium Age of Dinos

    Firestorm

    Mount Playstack

    Blizzard Bay

     

    Top 5 favorite to look at:

    Mongo Tropica

    Toreador

    Valle de Amanecer

    Hidden Kingdom

    Isla del Tesoro Perdido

  • Scoop%s's Photo

    Thanks Cocoa!! <3

Tags

  • No Tags

Members Reading