H2H8 / Ranking Parks on Two Fronts

Execution?

Concept? 

Which matters more for H2H, which allows people to take home the wins? 

I'm gonna eventually do something with this data, but for now, post two lists below. First, rate all 18 parks so far on their level of execution, meaning regardless of the theme, how well did they execute that theme? Second, rate all 18 parks so far on their concept, meaning how creative/new was the concept for the entire park, regardless of how well they executed it?

I'll eventually compile all the lists, establish an average position for each park, and then plot the averages. I'm interested to see where the winners and losers fall!

Here's a list of all the parks in no particular order:

DKS
Dig Site
Mictlan
Ghibli
Tubiao
EVIL
CnC
All Coasters
Wit's End
Port Disney
Arendelle
Winkelheim
Meekong

Mzima
Flamengo
Motherland
Tahendo Zoo

Forum Caeleste

 

Creativity Rankings

Winklehelm

Mictlan

ACGTH

Wits End

Dig Site 4

EVIL

Mekong

Ghibli

Motherland

DKS

Tubaio

Arandelle

Mzima

Feira,

Forum,

C&C ,

Tahendo,

Port Disney

Total Rankings

This is just very subjective, why do you want to rank parks based on these 2 aspects? There are a lot more factors to take into consideration to make a ranking that is the most objective as possible. Some people find creativity important, others aesthetics, atmosphere, park composition, ride construction etc. I'm very curious why you want to rank parks just on these 2 factors.. Sorry, but this topic is kinda worthless, it's more or less the same as the round-up topic.

It stemmed from a discussion about Execution Vs Idea.

Its not about the other points that people use to find whether they like a park or not, its just finding out people's opinions on what they would consider to be the parks with the best execution vs the best idea/concept. It isn't asking for a ranking based on how much you like the park or what you think is the best, its asking for those 2 specific things because they are linked together, the execution of an idea against the actual idea itself.

Everything is subjective in life.

interesting that you chose the negative form rather than "finishedness". Do you think it's easier to tell how much is unfinished compared to how much is finished?

I could rate parks on anything, sure. I could even rate parks using a hundred different categories and make it as objective as I possibly can. All of that would be extremely time consuming and probably give the same answer as a more simple approach, which this topic is.

These two categories in particular are what people are discussing at the moment, with a park like CnC that's arguably less creative but executed very well, and a park like Winkelheim, which has an amazing creative idea but lacking execution. It's just a fun way to see if the winners so far this H2H are more on the execution or creative idea side. 

interesting that you chose the negative form rather than "finishedness". Do you think it's easier to tell how much is unfinished compared to how much is finished?

I modified my original post to use "concept" rather than "creativity" because that's a much better descriptor of what I'm looking for here.

"Some people find creativity important, others aesthetics, atmosphere, park composition, ride construction etc"

i'd consider all of these things "execution" over concept lol.

Bring in the bias!

shogo, I think aesthetics can be creativity as well, like I think Liampie is very creative with aesthetics (new creative object use to create beautiful buildings), cp6 can be very creative to create a new ride etc.. Another reason why this topic is worthless, as there is so much overlap.. But whatever, just my two cents I guess.

edit, I see you've changed 'creativity' to 'concept', lol. Now you take the topic into an whole other direction

edit, I see you've changed 'creativity' to 'concept', lol. Now you take the topic into an whole other direction

I really intended concept moreso than creativity, just was using the wrong word before. I think the people who wrote lists knew what my intention was.

Well, worthless is a bit harsh maybe, what I just meant is that imo this topic touches on things that are very subjective and can be interpreted in so many different ways, that it just is kinda the same as the round-up topic. But go ahead, I'll not further ruin your party