RCT Discussion / PPASTF - Pre-Panel Accolade Scoring Task Force

Hey everyone! The title says all really. Since NE5 gives us the opportunity, let's give all the pre-panel accolades a score! With this some of the old parkmakers can get their parkmaker status back, like Turtle and sacoasterfreak did today. There's no notification when a pre-panel accolade gets its final score, so we can keep a list here.

Panelists of NE, it would be cool if you could visit a couple of old parks to score them. Let's do this! And if you notice something has received a score, post it here and I'll update the list!

Legend

Post #1: Pre-panel LL accolades
Post #2: Pre-panel RCT2 accolades
Post #4: List of scored pre-panel accolades

Quintessential creations are marked with 'priority'.
(%)

LL - Panelist Votes

Done!

LL - Community Votes

Silver - bokti - Lake Laramie
Silver - bokti - Oceania Theme Park
Silver - Andrew - Echoes Of The Past
Design - Panther - Ornsomi Mountain Trading Company
Invitational - Micool - Dragon Realm
NE Group Park - NE's Florencia Valley
NE Group Park - Chateau Lake Amusement Park
NE Group Park - NE's Hidden Realm
NE Group Park - NE's IAAPA Convention
Danimation Spotlight - x-sector - Sunshine Gardens
Danimation Spotlight - sacoasterfreak - Crystal Horizons
Danimation Spotlight - sacoasterfreak - Legends: Timeless Tales
Danimation Spotlight - Greg Reese - Hersheypark
Danimation Spotlight - Corkscrewed - Rich Uncle Pennybag's Estate
Danimation Spotlight - Fatha' - Wild Wild West
Danimation Spotlight - Greg Moore - Land of Song and Dance
Danimation Spotlight - DanMacK - Adventures into Imagination
Danimation Spotlight - Buster - Dungeons, Dragons & Drops
Danimation Spotlight - Scuiggy - Salem Swamp
Danimation Spotlight - Tyler - Orange Valley
Danimation Spotlight - Schuessler - Lands of Adventure
Danimation Spotlight - Schuessler - Canterbury Falls

RCT2

Done!

Watkin Woods Amusement Park just got a score of 86.88%.

Scored:

LL

Spotlight - Fatha' - Busch Gardens San Simeon (92.50%)
- - - - -
Spotlight - natelox - Disney's Forgotten Kingdom (88.75%)
Spotlight - mantis - Walkman of My Brain (87.50%)
Spotlight - Fatha' - Disney's Movie Magic (87.50%)
Spotlight - x-sector, mantis & Toon - City of Dreams (86.25%)
Spotlight - RRP - Sea World Atlanta (86.25%)
Spotlight - Schuessler - Islands of Adventure Hollywood (84.38%)
Spotlight - natelox - The Aegean (83.75%)
Spotlight - Twisted - Baiht Oashyr Vel Thalloo (83.75%)
Spotlight - RRP - Busch Gardens Lichfield (83.75%)
Spotlight - natelox - Disney's Discovery Island (83.64%)
Spotlight - x-sector - Universal's Outrage (83.13%)
Spotlight - Nevis - Universal's Island Xtreme (82.50%)
Spotlight - Ozone - DreamWorks Great Australia (82.50%)
Spotlight - Fatha' - Tropico Horizons (82.50%)
Spotlight - Fatha' - Tropico Cove (81.88%)
Spotlight - Mala - Mount Sinister (81.11%)
Invitational - mantis - Age of Empires (81.11%)
Spotlight - Coaster Ed - egypTopia (80.63%)
Spotlight - Nevis - Atlantis: The Lost Empire (80.63%)
Spotlight - x-sector & posix - Audrix Towers (80.63%)
NE Group Park - NE's Masters Isle (80.63%)
Spotlight - bokti - Harakiri's Islands of Adventure (80.00%)
- - - - -
Spotlight - PyroPenguin - Disney Dreams (78.13%)
Spotlight - Foozycoaster - Visions Amusement Park (78.13%)
Spotlight - Butterfinger - Universal's Caribbean Seas Resort (78.13%)
Spotlight - Iris - Troy's Ancient Resort (78.13%)
Spotlight - x-sector - California DisneySea (77.22%)
Invitational - Evil WME - Candlelight Times (77.50%)
Spotlight - PyroPenguin - Aurora's Bay (77.50%)
Gold - x-sector - Disney Extreme Orlando (77.50%)
Spotlight - Coaster Ed & Blind Guardian - Cataclysm (76.88%)
Spotlight - vTd - Florida DisneySea (76.88%)
Spotlight - posix - Raindrop Riviera (76.67%)
Spotlight - aero21 - Cinescape East (76.25%)
Spotlight - natelox - Disney's Beautiful World (76.25%)
Design - Phatage - Fire Dragon (75.77%)
Silver - posix - Kronecraft's Allure Lake (75.63%)
Spotlight - Roomie - Snow Drop (75.63%)
Gold - aero21 - Disneyland Mid-America (75.00%)
Spotlight - Corkscrewed - Meadowbrooke Falls Thrill Park (75.00%)
Design - jusmith - Monsoon (74.38%)
Design - posix - Nagas (74.38%)
Spotlight - Roomie - Arnos Springs Resort (74.38%)
Gold - Ablaze - Vales of Crypt (74.09%)
Design - posix - Machete (73.75%)
Design - Loopy - Bodhisattva (73.75%)
Spotlight - natelox - Land of the Villain (73.75%)
Spotlight - Evil WME - Lost Era Resort (73.75%)
Gold - Benni - Coral Creek Adventure World (73.13%)
Design - mantis - =WildSurf= (73.13%)
Design - Loopy - Phoenix (72.50%)
Gold - Evil WME - Glyphindel Oasis Dunes (72.50%)
Silver - posix & Sanctuary - Atlas Infinitum (71.25%)
Silver - Ablaze - Portal of Heaven (70.83%)
Design - posix - Vulture (70.63%)
Gold - Prince - EverQuest: Waters of the Past (70.63%)
Gold - Toon - Stratford Fair (70.63%)
Gold/NE Group Park - Group Park - Amity Cove (70.00%)
Design - posix - Dragonslayer (70.00%)
- - - - -
Gold - Ozone - Warner Bros. Hawaiian Adventure (69.38%)
Design - Nevis - Kraken (68.75%)
Design - Nevis - SpitFire (68.75%)
Silver - Ozone - Forest of Nautica (68.75%)
Silver - CoasterWizard - Banana Republic (68.13%)
Silver - Tony - Tambora Lagoon Resort (68.13%)
Silver - Tony - Foreign Legacies (67.50%)
Silver - Prince - EverQuest: Mystic Realms (67.50%)
Spotlight - Panther - Elsinore Falls Theme Park (67.50%)
Silver - Ozone - Illusion Isle (66.88%)
Design - RRP - Great American Screamer (66.88%)
Design - HevyDevy - Composed (65.63%)
Silver - Evil WME - Universal's Tampa: Master's Legend (65.63%)
Silver - Ozone, Aviator & Ablaze - Mystilogica (65.00%)
Silver - Themeparkmaster - The Burning Secret (65.00%)
Silver - RCTU - Secrets of Venice (65.00%)
Silver - Andrew - Chronicles (65.00%)
Silver - thorpedo - Tulesian Islands (65.00%)
Silver - Twisted - Wasted Years (65.00%)
Silver - Evil WME - Universal's Lost World (64.45%)
Silver - Roomie - Insania (64.38%)
Design - bokti - Spider-Man (64.38%)
Silver - Butterfinger - The Outer Banks (63.75%)
Silver - Fatha' - Ancient Pastimes II (63.75%)
Design - Gwazi - Pharaoh (63.13%)
Gold - darkfire - Greendale (62.50%)
Silver - coasterMM - Zanzibar Shores (62.50%)
Silver - mantis & Nic - Europa Worldwide 2005 (62.50%)
Silver - Aviator - The Northern Territories (61.88%)
Silver - Roomie - Ville des Fleuves (61.88%)
Silver - Twisted - The Other World (61.88%)
Design - thorpedo - Crucifiction (61.25%)
Silver - Prince - EverQuest: Reign of Terror (61.25%)
Silver - Roberto Roboparks - Pinewood Grove Resort (60.63%)
Silver - Elrocko - Citrus Beach California (60.63%)
- - - - -
Silver - rctfreak2000 - Exile (59.38%)
Silver - Fanatic of RCT - Mountain Vista Amusement Park (59.38%)
Silver - RCTU - Legendary Tales (59.38%)
Silver - rctfreak2000 - Xanfia (59.38%)
Silver - Micool - Legends of the Loch (59.38%)
Silver - MightyMouse & yyo - Chapters of Amorphis (58.75%)
Silver - spiderman - Action Zone (58.75%)
Design - Ablaze - Immortal Monstrocity (57.50%)
Silver - Prince - EverQuest: Lands of Shadow (57.50%)
Design - Twisted - Head Hunter (56.25%)
Design - RRP - Son of Beast (55.00%)
Silver - Roberto Roboparks - Valleystorm Falls (55.00%)
Design - ioaguy - Trail Blazer (55.00%)
Silver - Micool - The Happy Place (54.38%)
Design - Nessy:Ride of Steel - Volcanic Advent (53.75%)
Silver - Ozone & Aviator - AO Convention (53.75%)
- - - - -
Design - Roomie - Swamp Fox (48.13%)
- - - - -
Design - iPark - Xcelerator (38.13%)



RCT2

Spotlight - sacoasterfreak - Rivers of Babylon (91.25%)
Spotlight - Turtle - Isole Calabria (90.63%)
- - - - -
Design - geewhzz & disneylhand - El Encierro (88.75%)
Spotlight - Kumba - Dimensions: Realms of Creation (87.50%)
Spotlight - Cedarpoint6 - Watkins Woods Amusement Park (86.88%)
Spotlight - JKay - Rocky Mountain Mystique (86.88%)
Design - geewhzz - SALGA (85.63%)
Gold - X250 - The Masterpiece (83.75%)
Spotlight - artist - Islands of Enchantment (83.13%)
Design - Titan - Arch Angel (83.13%)
Spotlight - Highball - DisneySea (83.13%)
Design - Cedarpoint6 - Firefly (82.69%)
Spotlight - Meretrix - Disney's Tilted Acres (82.50%)
Gold - Phatage - Six Flags Worlds of Excitement (81.25%)
Design - John - Musette (80.63%)
- - - - -
Spotlight - J K - Spellbrook Shore (79.38%)
Design - Phatage - Fright Nights (79.38%)
Design - Cedarpoint6 - Mountaineer (78.75%)
Spotlight - artist - Ports of Magia (78.75%)
Design - geewhzz - Kindred (77.50%)
Spotlight - Butterfinger - Euroscape (77.50%)
Spotlight - Turtle - Bijou Magique (77.50%)
Spotlight - Meretrix - Disney's Phantasia (77.50%)
Gold - Metropole - Tussaud's Boscastle Heights (77.50%)
Spotlight - JKay - Divinity Ridge (76.88%)
Gold - Kumba - Bayfront Parc (76.88%)
Gold - Highball - Disneyland Park (76.25%)
Design - artist - Urchin (75.63%)
Gold - artist - Busch Gardens Europe (76.25%)
Design - X250 - Kurakku (76.25%)
Spotlight - RCTNW - Marriott's Marine World (75.00%)
Gold - Faceman - Paradise Island (74.38%)
Design - Kevin - Helios (74.28)
Design - sloB - Solaris (74.38%)
Design - Fatha' - Batman Night Flyer (73.75%)
Design - Marshy - Chamonix (73.75%)
Design - Turtle - Silverstarr (73.65%)
Design - Fr3ak - Charybdis (73.50%)
Gold - zburns999 - Paramount's Xtreme (73.13%)
Design - Turtle - Firebird (72.50%)
Gold - Metropole - Soul Calibur (71.88%)
Design - J K - Cape Congo (71.88%)
Silver - Splash-0 - Port Azure (71.25%)
Design - Faceman - El Fuego (71.25%)
Design - sloB - Hawkeye (71.25%)
Spotlight - aero21 - Aero's Wormwood (70.63%)
Gold - Six Frags - Mystique (70.63%)
Gold - aero21 - Walt's Disneyland Utopia (70.63%)
Gold - Pawn - Emperor of the Forgotten Realms (70.00%)
- - - - -
Design - Cedarpoint6 - Blizzard (68.75%)
Design - posix - Cannonball (68.75%)
Silver - Cedarpoint6 - The Black Lagoon (68.75%)
Spotlight - Corkscrewed - DisneySEA Spain (68.13%)
Design - J K - Tolán (68.13%)
Design - egg_head - Big Bear (68.13%)
Silver - AustinPowers - Roman Epic (68.75%)
Gold - Fantastico - Fantastic Wonders (68.50%)
Design - FK+Coastermind - Karizima (68.13%)
Design - Fisch - Mordred (67.78%)
Silver - Kumba & Titan - Tiumba - The Lost Islands (67.50%)
Silver - Ride6 - International Odyssey (67.50%)
Design - Faceman - Dueling Dragons (67.50%)
Gold - JKay - Universal Hawaii (66.88%)
Design - J K - Siren (66.88%)
Silver - CF - Cedar Creek (66.88%)
Design - egg_head - Formula-1 (66.88%)
Design - Splash-0 - The Beasts (66.88%)
Gold - Junya Boy - Mysterious Islands: Lost at Sea (66.88%)
Silver - JKay, Marshy & Ride6 - Madly Joyful Realms (66.25%)
Design - Kumba - Genus Carcharodon (66.25%)
Design - Jazz - Quest for the Forbidden Mountain (66.25%)
Design - Steve - Avenger (66.11%)
Design - Metropole - Lucifer's Angels (65.63%)
Silver - CoasterForce - Portrait of Heaven (65.63%)
Silver - aero21 - Warner Bros. Reel Adventures (65.00%)
Design - Fisch - Buccaneer (65.00%)
Design - Kumba & JKay - X-Men (65.00%)
Gold - RCTNW & rwadams - The NASCAR Experience (65.00%)
Silver - Kumba - Iron Wood Valley (64.50%)
Design - RRP - Vesuvius Stampede (64.50%)
Silver - Beejer - PARK 360 (64.38%)
Gold - RCTMajesty - Majestic Paradise (64.38%)
Design - zodiac - Silhouette (63.75%)
Design - RCFanB&M - Beowulf (63.75%)
Silver - Carl - Big Timber Creek Park (63.13%)
Silver - JKay & Richie - Mystic Sands (63.13%)
Design - Splash-0 - Over the Top (63.13%)
Silver - Six Frags - Puysegur Point Themepark (62.50%)
Design - JKay - Blue Thunder (62.50%)
Gold - Mike Robbins & MickMaximus - Myths, Legends, and Folklore (62.50%)
Silver - Junya Boy - Garden of Desires (62.00%)
Design - disneylhand - The Hunchback of Notre Dame (61.88%)
Gold - aero21 - Cinescape TV (61.25%)
Silver - Beejer - Moonbase Amusement Park (61.25%)
Silver - Ride6 - Waters of Civilization (60.91%)
Silver - Ride6 - Sunburst Shores (60.50%)
Silver - Kumba - Nirvana (60.50%)
Silver - Ride6 & Splash-0 - Lake Rash Mount (60.00%)
Design - Geoff - Lumeria (60.00%)
Design - Loopy - Vermillion (60.00%)
Silver - Ge-Ride - Igno Reme (60.00%)
Silver - chapelz - Lake Windermere (60.00%)
Silver - Peeee - Peeee Entertainment Studios (60.00%)
Design - DelLagos - Yggdrasil (60.00%)
- - - - -
Silver - RCTNW & Kai - Klamath Lake Amusement Park (59.50%)
Gold - Group Park - Archicon (58.75%)
Silver - gymkid dude & Scarface - Paradise Falls (58.75%)
Silver - Turtle - Tula City (58.50%)
Silver - Titan - Six Flags Hoosier Station (58.50%)
Silver - supertrooper - Big Top Circus Park (58.50%)
Silver - Metropole - John Williams: Through The Ages (58.00%)
Silver - sboarder - Cascades Amusement Park (58.00%)
Silver - BChillerR - Destination: Xtreme (57.50%)
Silver - JKay - ThrillZone Amusement Park (57.27%)
Silver - AustinPowers - BABYLON (57.00%)
Silver - Six Frags & sloB - Mount Frost Amusements (57.00%)
Design - Corkscrewed - Coyote Runner (57.00%)
Silver - RCTMasters - Acorn Springs (57.00%)
Silver - The Judge - Mysterious Realms (57.00%)
Silver - Twisted - Kimmeragh Glen (56.50%)
Silver - JKay - Entertainment City: Las Vegas (56.50%)
Design - DelLagos - Toxicity (56.25%)
Design - Jacko Shanty - Toxygen (56.25%)
Silver - JDP - Korsareian Valley (55.63%)
Silver - Rct Flame - Tinted Shores (55.00%)
Silver - Kumba - Dimensions (55.00%)
Silver - Beejer - Greater America (55.00%)
Design - Turtle - Merlinwood Express (55.00%)
Silver - JDP - Superior Amusement Park (55.00%)
Design - Roomie - Tribal Storm (54.00%)
Silver - Junya Boy - Dez-Morais Amusements (52.50%)
Silver - BChillerR - Two Shades of Pink (50.91%)
- - - - -
Silver - Roberto Roboparks - Pike Creek (43.00%)
Silver - Mike Robbins - Magnolia Gardens (41.50%)

are all these scores new? because damn this is nice. also this means we get some new legendary parkmakers! congrats sacoasterfreak and turtle! if you guys are even still here to enjoy it (hope so!)

Are you suggesting we vote them at what they would likely be today, or just try to vote them into a position to win whatever accolade they've already gotten?

Are you suggesting we vote them at what they would likely be today, or just try to vote them into a position to win whatever accolade they've already gotten?

Vote on them as if the panel was around when the park came out. Of course you shouldn't add 20% just because a park is old, but neither should you give low scores because something is underdetailed or has been done better since. Be reasonable. If you're on the panel, we trust you not to be an idiot. It's possible that the score won't correspond with the modern accolade requirements, but this doesn't affect the accolade type. For example, aero's Cinescape TV is still a gold despite a 61% score.

If you're on the panel, we trust you not to be an idiot.

 

That might be the crucial mistake

Trying to vote on as many as I can. Currently my LL is not working properly so I cant vote on them

Trying to vote on as many as I can. Currently my LL is not working properly so I cant vote on them

 

 

Since we're on the subject of task forces I think we need a task force to raise awareness for the GOG path for LL. For like 3 bucks and a minimal time investment of like 30 minutes everyone can have LL. I never knew how easy it was to get it working but after doing it it's a real shame there are so many people without LL.

we trust you not to be an idiot.

 

 

is this why i'm not a panelist yet?

Trying to vote on as many as I can. Currently my LL is not working properly so I cant vote on them

 

Don't rush it! There's no hurry. This project will take years.

 

is this why i'm not a panelist yet?

 

That, and because you're TOO eager, and because you don't know who Turtle and sacoasterfreak are.

Oh my god gdb, if you don't know who Turtle is I'm going to break your face.

 

It's possible that the score won't correspond with the modern accolade requirements, but this doesn't affect the accolade type. For example, aero's Cinescape TV is still a gold despite a 61% score.

Okay, good call. I'll try to get through a bunch over the weekend.

Anyone else who knows who Turtle and sacoasterfreak are, and would like to help out, send a PM to me, Louis and inthemanual. Being a panelist on NE5 is different from being a panelist on NE4; you don't have to actively participate as much. If you vote only once per month, you're still most welcome! If you know who Turtle and sacoasterfreak are, of course. Don't hesitate, PM us!

i know who turtle is, and sacoasterfreak, and all the other former parkmakers. i've been looking at the parks on here for 2 years now liam... i've looked through the datebase more than a few times

I've been voting as I normally would for these which would explain my lower scores.. Whoops.

70% for Watkins Woods, what the fuck Poke. You can't vote 70% on a park that groundbreaking.

whaaat the fuck poke
you seriously think wwap is only low-gold quality

question, liam. will silvers that get below 60 be changed to bronze, or vice versa. what about golds/spotlights?

i can't say shit thought because i only gave drc an 80...

nope old accolades stay from what i can tell

I guess I must've missed something as I thought it was sterile. :/ Well, i've been voting normally and if that park was released now, I would've gave it 70%.