Releases / H2H6 - RR R2: The Replacements vs Flying Germans

Definately Tivoli Gardens for me.

Park Edda , what a amazing wooden coaster omfg the best i've seen in RCT

I decided to vote for the Team Flying Germans.

I was expecting some kick ass stuff from replacements like a sea of sagas, not a generic with high detailed park.
yeah, It's certainly one of greatest realistic park ever but It's just didn't hold my attention longer.

Pork Edna

I vote for Tivoli Gardens. Will add reviews later on.

I won't have time for a full review, but I thought both parks were really good. Tivoli was great, I liked the scenic railway and the detailed archy, but I think there was a little something missing in the atmosphere. I think maybe it was a bit to clean and tidy, I kinda like parks that are a little messy. 8th Wonder was awesome, nice touch trying a duel color sign. 7.7/10.0

Edda was awesome. I loved the frozen waterfall/creek and the Midgard Serpent. Just the better atmosphere imo and I think the themeing flowed well. Great rides too. Not that close a match-up imo... 8.6/10.0

Vote: Park Edda

In the style of Six Frags a short review from my side.

My vote goes to The Replacements, their park is clearly beter. The idea, the architecture the overall feeling etc. The Flying Germans park is bad but their unfinished product has no change against the replacements park.

Anyway some highlights out of the parks.

Tivoli Gardens

Brilliant:


Just wow!


The station, the buildings, the road just so perfect!


Historical correct to build a courtyard


Just great architecture!

Not like:

(It was really hard to find things I didn't like in the park, the only one I could find was this one)

This one just don't work. Mehh.


Park Edda:

Brilliant:


THAT DRAGON, THAT DRAGON!


The pirate ship works!


Best mack supports so far, perfect!

Not likes:
It was really a shame that this park is not finished in potential it got so many great spots.


I hope this was not finished?


Why make the suggestion that, that mountain is fake what gives it the park extra?


Mehh, this survival parcour just sucks, seen beter ones.


After all it wher 2 really strong parks, thank you builders!


(Note: sorry my English sucks I know)

Hey RMM, isn't this blowout entertaining?

I will say that, while I enjoyed Tivoli, like others, I found myself bored fairly quickly, which wasn't aided by the fact that a lot of the park seemed like it was attempted before and attempted better. The archy especially felt like 5dave-lite, which is odd considering you have the real thing on your team.

Again, a difficult match.
Tivoli Gardens was wonderful. Very atmospheric, though not necessarily the atmosphere of the real Tivoli or Copenhagen. That was probably not the aim, but it would immediately have won me over.
In the end I felt though that it was a bit generic. Everything was beatiful, but nothing really wowed me.

Park Edda was very different. It was, sadly, much less consistent, with a lot of unfinished parts, and random/boring naming. Ragnarök is just soooo obvious and to put a "Viking Ship" into a Norse park is even less inspired than the "Merchant ship" we put in our round 1 park (sorry Liam). Also a readme would have helped those that aren't so familiar with the Edda (me for example). On the other hand there were parts of great amazingness, especially many of the ornaments for the houses were just fascinating and very creative.

At the moment I'd tend to vote for Edda, but I'm not sure and thus NOT voting yet.

a really damn close match, at the end i think both are equal. the quality is better in park edda, but the fact that this one looks unfinished in some places turns it back to the same point i see tivoli gardens. the atmosphere is in both parks equal imo. so i only see two winners here and no result, but fortunately others see a result. if park edda would have been finished, that one would have been the winner in my eyes... but so...

After many many hours of viewing both parks, my vote is going to go the The Replacements' Tivoli Gardens. I felt the style of this park to be more aesthetically pleasing, and i overall had more fun viewing it than Park Edda. Though both parks were very well done, and applause to both teams for creating such great parks.

I think the votes are currently at 20 - 11.

Im voting for the germans. That coaster was beast and the area around was very nice, Didn't know what the names of the rides was or the theme but i got a norse feeling from it. Some areas looked unfinished but im willing to overlook them as i enjoyed everything else especially the water/boat ride and the viking ship and the dragons head

With the replacements i also enjoyed this but i felt the coasters let it down. the mountain valley train thing was really good and so was the architecture but overall it didn't hold my attention as much as the other park and it also reminded me of olympic village.

Vote: Germans

Pork Edna

Been there...done that.


3:06

KONG=Life of the party.

Actually, Edna was


3:06

I had a tortoise called Edna.

Yada Yada. Back to voting please

Don't you want to know about my tortoise? It died.


But yeah seriously, a few more votes would be appreciated. It feels a little like the voting turnout for R2 has gone down a fair bit from R1.

Guys please more votes and criticsm/reviews and less tortoise/edna/whatever talk.
The activity is a shame compared to week1.

"MFG"