Micro Madness / #2 J K vs. #10 ride_exchanger

Round 2 - Match-Up #5: J K vs. ride_exchanger

#2 J K with his entry:
De Stijl Gardens



#10 ride_exchanger with his entry:
Old School



After 6 votes by the judges, the winner, by a score of 4 to 2, is... J K

J K moves on to the Sweet 16 where he will face the winner of the Ride6 vs. Lloyd match-up.

it's no Hotel Yorba but i really like what you have there, J K.

Both very nice, but I think J K was the deserved winner here.

I love that coloring job, J K.

I really like it J K and you know i do .

ooo.

that's awesome, J K.

J K's theme and it's execution were great. Can't say I loved the coaster, but it was pretty good.

r_e you did a nice coaster, but the rest was not much to look at so J K would be my clear-cut pick here. Seems you managed 2 votes anyways, so congrats on that

A really great entry on JK's part. One of the better ones we've seen this contest in terms of theming. I'm not a fan of the two lifts on the thing, but for what it is, the coaster is nice-- I thought the placement of the water section was really well done. But overall, the whole concept was really nice-- very cool idea and I'm glad to see you did research and everything to make it look right. There were some great ideas sprinkled throughout.

R_E had an ok coaster, although I didn't like the curved lift section. Overall, though, it felt a lot like ride6's entry, just less themed. Not a bad shot, but JK had a great entry.

Sorry JK, my heart just wasnt in this anymore. I think everyone can tell I barely tried with this entry. I just wanted to make sure you had an actual opponent this round. And Kudos to those who voted for me! I must have some friends in the voting pool, cause I can't believe I got any votes.


As to your concept JK, I like the fact you picked an artisitc theme, but I happen to strongly dislike this particular style of art. But you did execute it well, and obviously put alot more work into your entry then I did into mine. So congrats and good luck in the next round!

Edited by ride_exchanger, 25 December 2007 - 08:50 PM.

lol at the readme telling you to read the actual readme.
nice work, JK. seemed a bit rushed in some places. still a deserved win.
r_e, yours was nice, but too simple

J_K: I liked it, it was very aesthetical pleasing and the coaster was nice. Nothing spectacular or overwhelming, it was just nice and solid. I liked the art-inspired architecture.

R_E: Yeha - Old school! Plus for the Peep-friendliness. I liked your first entry a lot more, though. Nothing really else to comment on.

"MFG"