(Archive) Advertising District / Dump-Place
- 19-April 07
-
Louis! Offline
The right hand side is very nice, as is the very far left. But the middle is just too much of a cluster fuck. You seem to really like overdetailing it just creates mess that to me isn't pleasant to look at. Where as the far left and the right of the building works very well as it's got the right amount of detail. -
SSSammy Offline
you're never going to be as good as sey at "overdetailing" robbie
although i have no idea what that is, cause in my eyes, thats really damn pretty. -
Splitvision Offline
left and right is brilliant, the middle a little too brilliant, making it less so. I almost feel that despite it being so detailed, it feels unfinished. Like there's still some scaffolding around the house and they started building a little here and a little there but never really finished any part completely... But it's mightily impressive nonetheless (thats one word right?) -
Sey Offline
I thought my stuff isn't even that overdetailed, Sammy. Everything makes sence here: (for me)
Robbie, I like that! Works fine I think...
Edited by Sey, 03 January 2010 - 09:16 AM.
-
Fr3ak Offline
Oh come on.
Stop posting so interesting screens everyone!
You make me look bad!
Second page.I thought my stuff isn't even that overdetailed, Sammy. Everything makes sence here: (for me)
Robbie, I like that! Works fine I think... -
Casimir Offline
talking about overdetailed o_O
well, I think it looks quite excellent... really, I'm kind of overwhelmed. if you manage to give it a nice background facade, this'll be ace. -
J K Offline
I'm actually not impressed by either which really surprises me considering I love both of your work. -
SSSammy Offline
haha, i dont think its overdetailed at all sey, as ive told you before.
i think people throw it about abit.
i love robbies screens, and i love "overdetail"
youre skilled builders and i know theres nothing there which isnt placed with care and precision. -
zburns999 Offline
Robbie's is actually pretty good. Still too overdetailed, but at least it has really nice form and shows obvious planning. Sey, sorry man, but that just looks like a complete mess to me. -
zodiac Offline
i don't think it's overdetailed. i mean, yeah, there's a lot of pieces, so it looks busy, but every object there contributes to the look. -
Louis! Offline
Its a complete and utter mess. I can't focus on a single thing. All I see is deco pieces. I cant seem to make any real form from them. Way to overdetailed, I dont see why people seem to think by adding shit loads of detail is going to make something good.
Tags
- No Tags