Music Forum / The Official "What are you listening to?" Thread
- 27-January 07
-
Ruben Offline
You don't know much about drums, do you?
Buddy Rich - drum solo
I've been playing them for 8 years now, so I guess I actually do. And I'm far from the only one that sees him as one of the best drummers ever.
The thing is, his technique might not be the hardest/most complex to master there has ever been. But he was just só creative and inventive. He created something new almost everytime he played, with unique sounds and beats, something not many drummers can say.
Problem is... there are so many (especially jazz/soul) drummers that simply believe one's level is measured by the amount of random toms hit per minute... It's been done a thousand times before, it's not a pleasing sound, and imho it's not much more than a funny trick. It's difficult, but that doesn't automatically make it good. There's no feeling in it.
Having that said:
Avenged sevenfold
Nightmare. -
pierrot Offline
* Gaetano Parisio (ita)
Needind Chords
Advanced Techno Research 1/10 [A - Side]
Chapter Four [ B - Side]
* Danilo Vigorito (ita)
Tobecon -
Dr_Dude Offline
Yeah man jazz has no feeling at all let's go listen to Avenged Sevenfold.Problem is... there are so many (especially jazz/soul) drummers that simply believe one's level is measured by the amount of random toms hit per minute... It's been done a thousand times before, it's not a pleasing sound, and imho it's not much more than a funny trick. It's difficult, but that doesn't automtically make it good. There's no feeling in it.
-
Ruben Offline
Yeah man jazz has no feeling at all let's go listen to Avenged Sevenfold.
You're misreading what I'm saying. I say there are many drummers that only look at the level of difficulty of technique, while not putting any feeling in their music. And I point out that íf I see that happneing it's mostly with Jazz/soul drummers. That's very different from the idea that all Jazz has no feeling. Guess I'd be the last one to say that since I love listening to Django Reinhardt, Dave Brubeck, New Cool Collective and so many other great jazz musicians.
Try to be critical about your way of reading before being critical about what you thínk a text says. Keeps you from posting dumbass 1 sentence comments. Just saying.
Having that said:
Kyteman's orchestra
Sorry -
Ruben Offline
Good idea.
So Far Away
We can talk.
Avenged Sevenfold
A little piece of heaven
Somewhat disturbing subject... but the arrangement is just insanely good. -
A.S.Coasters Offline
^Definitely, here's another great one.
Critical Acclaim
Jimmy's voice sounds amazing in this song, skip to 2:32. -
Ruben Offline
Rise against
Chamber the Cartridge
Good Music
Good People
Good Message +
__________________
Full of win. -
Dr_Dude Offline
You're misreading what I'm saying. I say there are many drummers that only look at the level of difficulty of technique, while not putting any feeling in their music. And I point out that íf I see that happneing it's mostly with Jazz/soul drummers. That's very different from the idea that all Jazz has no feeling. Guess I'd be the last one to say that since I love listening to Django Reinhardt, Dave Brubeck, New Cool Collective and so many other great jazz musicians.
It's not mostly jazz and soul drummers who strive for pure difficulty, it's mostly metal drummers. Literally the only drummers I get any sense of "feeling" from are jazz drummers and Zach Hill (I'm a drummer bee tee dubs). Anywhere else it's just percussion to me. But I'm sure the way I would define "feeling" in music is different from the way you see it, so it's probably just semantics.
PS you should listen to some jazz made by black people. It's better.
And right now I'm listening to The Money Store by Death Grips, who leaked the album themselves. It's a fucking banger. -
verti Offline
I've been playing them for 8 years now, so I guess I actually do. And I'm far from the only one that sees him as one of the best drummers ever.
The thing is, his technique might not be the hardest/most complex to master there has ever been. But he was just só creative and inventive. He created something new almost everytime he played, with unique sounds and beats, something not many drummers can say.
How is doing what everyone else is doing creative? He didn't do it to any particular level, and there's certainly nothing 'unique' to his sound. I'm sorry, but he's just another dime-a-dozen, overhyped by the little emo fanbase the band has produced.Problem is... there are so many (especially jazz/soul) drummers that simply believe one's level is measured by the amount of random toms hit per minute... It's been done a thousand times before, it's not a pleasing sound, and imho it's not much more than a funny trick. It's difficult, but that doesn't automatically make it good. There's no feeling in it.
To say that drummers like Buddy Rich are only about speed and technique is absolutely preposterous. The amount of feeling and devotion you can hear when that man is playing is insane - and that's coming from a rock drummer. And even if you can't understand that, it's guys like him and gene Krupa that redefined percussion in music, and that demands respect no matter what.
</rant>
Hammerfall - Blood Bound -
Ruben Offline
Dr. Dude: Meh, some metal drummers have the same problem yeah. Just don't listen to Metal as much because a lot of it usually doesn't interest me anyway. I agree about the black Jazz musicians, but that's nothing new to me (thankfully).
Verti: Guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one.... We can keep on going, but I'll just call it a matter of taste instead. I'm not saying drummers like Buddy Rich didn't do anything for drumming, or that they are bad. Just saying it's not my idea of the essence of drumming. It is not my idea of feeling, devotion maybe, but not feeling. No shame in disagreeing on this right?
Buena vista social club
Hasta Siempre commandante
Tags
- No Tags