(Archive) Advertising District / Project Logos
- 05-January 07
-
Liampie Offline
I don't like this one. I don't recognize the bobble-head and I don't see how this relates to science. It might work in another park but in this park it seems like filler. Especially having a blown up [something], whatever it is, is usually an indication that your idea is bad.
There's so much stuff going on in this park (I assume), it's not a shame to have one shop/detal less. DRC and Roman Vice were great because ALL the details were good. Zombieland was equally detailed but there were more filler details. It's not your park, but this goes for the Olympic Village as well. Quality over quantity, even if both matter. -
Disney Imagineer Offline
I just read over this whole thread and think this park is pretty cool. I don't usually get into fantasy parks much (more of a realistic park fantatic) but this was fun to read over and look at. Nice bobblehead. That's a neat concept. Love the Big Bang Theory attraction (love that show).
God I haven't seen that mouse car in so long that I forgot they had eyes. I was like...where the hell did he get that? lol -
nin Offline
I just figured that with all of your parkmaker awards you'd be able to determine what looks good and what doesn't.
Anyways, the park is technically "ugly" simply for the fact that there's not much going on aesthetically. Nothing ties anything together. Sure the theme of "science" connects the dots, but not on the theme park level. This is just a collection of ideas thrown onto a map, ranging from big to small to tiny. There really aren't any suggestions to give to fix that as you're already too far along.
Both you and Ryan can make good-looking parks (Not sure if you know this, but X is my favorite parkmaker out there), and both of you are known for having good ideas and such, but that's all this park is. Ideas. It's like you went into this wanting to have the best "little things" in a park ever, but I think that's the best you're going to get. -
5dave Offline
^I agree with nin here. But that's just Kumba's style. Some people like it, some don't. IMO the park is like a sketchbook for a theme park instead of a park itself.
But keep doing what you're doing Kumba - it works, as your rank proves it. And maybe the girls like this park too!
"MFG" -
Louis! Offline
It looks ugly
Edit: In all seriousness, the details going into this are immense, but I do agree with what nin says, whilst the details will be great, I can't help but think the park as a whole will lack aesthetics. -
Corkscrewy Offline
I can understand what nin is saying. And I don't think he means that it looking ugly is a bad thing in this scenerio. I totally understand what he's saying and I think this looks amazing. Ugly, sure, but that's mainly cuz theres so much awesome sciency shit going on.
and I hope i'm not the only one that realizes that that bobble head will actually have a bobbling head back and forth. because thats amazing. -
AvanineCommuter Offline
Nin is completely right. I don't want to be repeating things since I agree with everything he said, but Kumba's style is just like that - either you're super realistic and clean (ala Kumba), or super "little things" oriented (ala D:RoC). The former is aesthetically pleasing whereas the latter isn't so much, but that doesn't mean the "little things" aren't worthy of high marks or praise. It's just a different style. Not my personal taste, but I recognize the ingenuity that is required to build that way. I sure as hell can't.
This park seems to be a bunch of little things that will create an amazing park as a whole as well, so the comments are not really a slight against you. I mean, can you realistically defend your position and say that your aesthetic considerations here are as high as, let's say, Disney American Waterfront? -
Luketh Offline
EDIT: Aaaaand doublepost. Sorry..? D: I like the rockclimbing wall in the top left screen! -
Kumba Offline
Well, it's an underground section of the park. I think you, or someone can figure it out. -
Kumba Offline
Not too thrilled with the current amounts of feedback, but I have been showing fairly small teaser screens, so let's try something a little larger...
Happy 4th of July -
BelgianGuy Offline
while it's good work it's just so hard to focus on something because it looks kinda messy and unoriganised in places, I know it's an undergrond section and all but science and research facilities always seem to have some kind of logical structure behind it, something I am kinda missing here...
Tags
- No Tags