Park / Area 51

  • 12-January 05
Park_927 Area 51

Choose the better park.

  1. Flying Germans: Area 51 24 votes [28.24%]
    Percentage of vote: 28.24%
  2. Vehemences: Rainbow Valley 61 votes [71.76%]
    Percentage of vote: 71.76%
poll closed - 93 votes Vote

43 Comments

This park shares comments with 1 other park(View Park)
  • Corkscrewed%s's Photo
    Corkscrewed Offline
    Flying Germans
    Area 51

    Wk3-FlyG-A51-Scr1.jpgWk3-FlyG-A51-Scr2.jpg

    Wk3-FlyG-A51-Map.jpg

    DOWNLOAD HERE


    Vehemences
    Rainbow Valley

    Wk3-Vehe-RV-Scr1.jpgWk3-Vehe-RV-Scr2.jpg

    Wk3-Vehe-RV-Map.jpg

    DOWNLOAD HERE



    WEEK 4 parks are due on JANUARY 20, 2005.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Steve%s's Photo
    United States Steve Offline
    I miss Future Aspects. :(

    Vehemences get my vote. The Germans did good, but it kind of bored me, a bit.

    Good architecture though, of what was there.
    and funky tunnels!
    posted 20 years ago
  • Roomie%s's Photo
    United Kingdom Roomie Offline
    Now this is more like it.
    2 very good ideas.

    I think Rainbow Valley pulled idea off very well where as A51 didnt quite do it. A bit too empty (i guess it is in a desert) but a few more buildings would of done it. It did have some charm though.

    RV gets my vote.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Kumba%s's Photo
    United States Kumba Offline
    Well I liked both...

    A-51 was ok, good idea tho its been done befor (that really old LL one from Doctor J's site.) you just did not do enof when their was SO much you could have done. You did have some nice archy tho, it was good, just to empty.

    RV - Im a sucker for duelers, the 2 here were great, so was the colors idea, but again it kinda reminds me of another park; Tinted Shores by RCT Flame, so no very high creativity points there. I enjoyed the park and the only beef I had was with the 1/4 black box/stones, don't use them like that, it was just ugly.

    RV got my vote, congrats on what should be your first win.
    posted 20 years ago
  • iris%s's Photo
    United States iris Offline
    This is very one sided for me.
    Vehemences crafted a very nice looking park...whereas the Flying Germans just...didn't in my opinion.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Jacko Shanty%s's Photo
    United States Jacko Shanty Offline
    This is very very similar to the other battle, except I think this is the one that should be closer. For instance, Area 51 had some amazing ideas... I absolutely loved the virginia reels. The archiecture was cool too. But it just wasn't a full park. Like The Cave, it was a good idea with not much there. But RV was great... amazing duelers, nice architecture, a FULL park.. yeah ok hello. If A51 was a full park, then it would gmv instantly.. love those tunnels.

    So I voted for RV.
    posted 20 years ago
  • cg?%s's Photo
    United States cg? Offline
    Ah, brilliant. Many times with H2H I find two equally average, and boring, parks, and am forced to vote for the most beautiful. This matchup, however, I find two equally creative, and unique, parks, and am forced to vote for the most beautiful. Frankly, it is a choice I make with much more enjoyment, and also much more sorrow, because I have to vote against a truly amazing park!

    Anyways, I have to vote for Rainbow Valley, but wish I could vote for them both! Wonderful work both of you.

    PS: Yes, I am in an especially good mood tonight... hopefully it will last...
    posted 20 years ago
  • Geoff%s's Photo
    United States Geoff Offline
    Rainbow Valley projected its idea better.

    RV gets my vote.
    posted 20 years ago
  • JKay%s's Photo
    United States JKay Offline
    Area 51 - Well, another park that lacked in the execution department. The ideas were there, but there were numerous flaws that immediately locked my vote to the Vehmences. Mainly, the landscaping. I realize the setting was in a desert, but the flatness was just disturbing, to the point I felt like I was looking a blank workbench in places. The architecture, what was there, was well-formed and stylish. I woulda loved to see more of it. The coaster however, I did not like. It spent the majority underground, making it hard to follow. The Virginia Reel was not a bad idea, but again, execution lacked too much to keep me interested. A good effort guys, but definitely a below-par park for me.


    Rainbow Valley - I loved this park. If you're ever gonna do a rainbow theme, this is the way to go; make everything a rainbow. The park flowed pretty much perfectly, from the architecture to the track supports, quite flawless (except for that damn zero divide error :@ ) . Duelers were awesome and as most know, I'm a sucker for RCT2 colors being used like this, so I almost immediately knew this park had my vote. One flaw imo would be that the architecture depended heavily on 2x2 in several places, but not really to the point that the buildings were not interesting to look at. And the atmosphere doesnt get much more pleasant than this. Awesome park guys.

    Vehmences get my vote.
    posted 20 years ago
  • chapelz%s's Photo
    United States chapelz Offline
    I think JKAY summed up how I felt about this match. And just take a wild guess at who I voted for. ;)
    posted 20 years ago
  • tracidEdge%s's Photo
    United States tracidEdge Offline
    If it there was more in it, and I wasn't on the Vehemences, I would have voted for Area 51. The architecture was a lot better imo, but this just doesn't compare to the vibrant colors in Rainbow Valley. Deserts don't have to be flat with nothing in them...I think.

    Anyway, vehemences get my vote.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Corkscrewed%s's Photo
    Corkscrewed Offline

    Ah, brilliant. Many times with H2H I find two equally average, and boring, parks, and am forced to vote for the most beautiful. This matchup, however, I find two equally creative, and unique, parks, and am forced to vote for the most beautiful. Frankly, it is a choice I make with much more enjoyment, and also much more sorrow, because I have to vote against a truly amazing park!

    Anyways, I have to vote for Rainbow Valley, but wish I could vote for them both! Wonderful work both of you.

    PS: Yes, I am in an especially good mood tonight... hopefully it will last...

    *sigh*

    Sometimes I think you just purposely go against the grain in an attempt to annoy everyone else. :p

    Anyway, I did not find either particularly awesome, tho Rainbow Valley was pretty nice. I'm not sure why people aren't saying the same thing about it as they did with Paradise Island. It's the same stuff we've seen only with different colors. If you're gonna be fussy with one, why not the other?

    And I found Area 51 to be simply a poor excuse for an unfinished park.

    Of course, I've seen you (cg?) take a recent swing toward more scenario-istic style parks, so I can understand why you like it... I just don't agree. :D

    In any case, at least I was right about thinking THIS matchup would be a slaughter... :D Congrats to the Vehemences for what appears to be a solid win (I won't call this until 24 hrs have passed at least. And I like more votes. :D).
    posted 20 years ago
  • jon%s's Photo
    Australia jon Offline
    Because I'm on the Flying Germans, my vote goes to Area 51 although I thought that Rainbow Valley was the better park.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Anolis%s's Photo
    Germany Anolis Offline
    I voted for Rainbow Valley

    Area 51: It wasn't a new idea to build a area 51. It ist more a standard idea.
    But the architecture was nice

    Rainbow Valley: Great Dueller and the colours were very good pulled together. When I look at this
    park I see a rainbow. The only bad thing imo was much 2x2 architecture
    posted 20 years ago
  • Valp%s's Photo
    United States Valp Offline
    I voted for team loyalty...

    But man, if only the original file hadn't been lost, with its main selling point...

    I'll be sure to check out RV later.
    posted 20 years ago
  • killing_moon%s's Photo
    United Kingdom killing_moon Offline
    I voted for the flying germans because any idiot who knows anything about rct (apart from machchunk) can whack every colour in the game into a park filled with tedious 2x2 oh-my-god-i-think-i'll-kill-myself-if-i-see-another-rip-of-euroscape architecture. Whereas actually creating a composed atmosphere, and leaving empty space which positively contributed to the park, whether it was a time issue or not, at least hasn't been done one hundred times before.
    posted 20 years ago
  • Evil WME%s's Photo
    Netherlands Evil WME Offline
    another horrible set of parks....

    i chose the flying germans one, because apart from the coaster, it was ok to look at. and empty, but atleast ok to look at.

    The rainbow park was nice, the duellers were ok i guess... but with a tap of "4" everything dissapears.. there's really not that much there either. Around the station there are a couple of rides, the water ride and a coaster. But no real landscaping, no purpose to the rest of the park (apart from being a sore in the eye kind of colorful)
    posted 20 years ago
  • cg?%s's Photo
    United States cg? Offline

    If you're gonna be fussy with one, why not the other?


    Well, as I said, for no reason in particular I found myself in wonderfully high spirits last night, and continue to feel that way this morning, and that was, and is, about 98% of it, really. Actually, I like Paradise Island a lot more at the moment than I did then, too (although I still prefer The Cave).

    And, yes, scenario-istic (what a brilliant word that is!), retro-2000, is the style of the moment. Well, for me, anyways.
    posted 20 years ago
  • mantis%s's Photo
    United Kingdom mantis Offline
    Definitely Rainbow Valley. I don't get Area 51 at all, really.
    posted 20 years ago
  • muuuh%s's Photo
    Germany muuuh Offline
    the Rainbow Valley gets my vote.
    the dueller is ok and its a nice idea. i like the style of the houses. looks very colorful

    muuuh
    posted 20 years ago