Park / Thira
-
22-May 07
- Views 915,449
- Downloads 772
- Fans 2
- Comments 1,093
-
2 fans Fans of this park
-
Download Park
772
-
Tags
nedesigns
- Copyright © 2002-2024 New Element Designs
-
Community Forum Software by IP.Board
Results !!!!
Results !!!!
Who goes to be the champion of this round?
I wait that it earns optimum !
Best Wooden Coaster
By far the hardest round I have judged yet. We have two winners this round. Ling and Vekoma9 both turned in some really good entries in a round that had no clear winner. Also hugely aiding both winners was the fact that they each just barely missed getting NE design twice in this year and then add the fact that one entry is RCT2 and the other LL it seemed reasonable that we have co-winners. Ling's entry was by far the best themed, but his coaster had some painfully slow section. Landscaping and theming put Ling into the PT3 finals. Vekoma9 had one of the best coaster layouts in the contest and his woodie had the best realistic details, just please work on your landscaping for the finals! In second place is Panic who arguable had the best layout, however the rest of his entry was boring and did not show that he was the big gun in the round. Lucas92 lands in third place with an entry that reminds me of egg_Head's from the water ride round, very nice and very small. Nice work Panic and Lucas, however your entries combined look like they were tossed together in 24 hours. CoasterAnne (Who is not a girl!) lands in 4th place with a good wooden coaster and some of the more interesting architecture I have seen in RCT2. Xin makes his third prelim appearance this round, however his snow themed entry was crashed by the avalanche that was the other 5 entries. Helping me judge this round was the PT1 wooden coaster prelim winner, thx for the help
1. Chaseur de Tresor by Ling (LL)
1. Gibalter by Vekoma9
2. Pioneer by Panic (LL)
3. Screamin' Bullet by Lucas92
4. Laovaa by CoasterAnne
5. Cold Front by Xin
Next round is the B&M and I will post a recap of who is heading up the hunt for a bonus spot. Good luck everyone!
Preliminary Rounds - Due Date:
FK+Coastermind Created The Best Bridge (May 14)
J K Created The Best Water Ride (May 21)
Geoff Created The Best Inverted Coaster (May 28)
Ling & Vekoma9 Created The Best Wooden Coaster (June 4)
Create The Best B&M (June 11)
Create The Best Adventure Ride (June 18)
Create The Best Dueling Coasters (June 25)
Create Any of the Above, a.k.a. "The Bonus Round") (July 2)
Wildcard! Create anything you want (July 9)
you're my personal winner here.
in my opinion, your entry had the best coaster and overall the highest aesthetic value.
not exactly realistic style parkmaking in my books, but i'm convinced you should dig into it more
i see a lot of young rrp in this. one of the greatest rctll players of all time.
i especially liked the flower-shrub-alignment. soooo sexy!
well done.
Ling I'm sorry but you're entry just didn't impress me much. From that awkward mid-course brake to the 9mph turn I really didn't care for your layout at all. Themeing was ok I guess. You're getting better at LL.
I go already to see these works and of the r my opinion!
Congrats Ling and Vekoma, will check the entries out as soon as I can
I wish I could see the LL entries. Can someone post a screen for them?
And another thing Good job Ling. Way to show nevada has some skills!
Ok, Took a look at the one's I could.
Lucas- I actually thought the station was nice. I loved it. The track was pretty good too. Good job on that. I thought yours was probably better then mine, but I'm not complaining.
Coaster Anne- Nice entry the layout was odd, but nice. I enjoyed it. one thing though was the buildings they confused me alot.
Xin- Your getting better. Just take more time to do it. Good luck on the following rounds.
Edited by vekoma9, 05 June 2007 - 03:29 PM.
Haha.. hope to see you at one of the bonus rounds man. And if you don't get in it's DUO time baby!!!!!
Added.
@OLE: I know what you mean about the pacing, as well as the mcbr. The reason I put the mcbr in where I did was to kind of set it up for the drop into the overgrown valley. And I tried to modify the speed a bit by adding in chainlifts in certain spots, but I couldn't do much
EDIT: I have now looked at all the parks, so...
Gibalter - Vekoma9
Great coaster layout; looked really nice. The touches and details underwater were great too. I look forward to your work in the final round.
Pioneer - Panic
Beautiful. I can't believe I won over this, as it is some really classic-looking LL. The pacing was great, the atmosphere was great... Amazing work, Panic.
Screamin' Bullet - Lucas92
I heard you say a while back. I'm so glad to see you still around, and your design was great. I <3 your station-making abilities.
Laovaä - CoasterAnne
The layout was awkward, but very cool. The out and back style of the middle bit was really cool, although somewhat slow on that one steep hill. Your architecture was interesting, but unfortunately not that great IMO... The stained glass and castle walls were great, but the other buildings just seemed weird and beyond unrealistic. Good Fantasy style, I suppose?
Cold Front - Xin
I can't say much for this... Although I see you, like me, used brake slowing for effect. I liked that. But try to make sure that if you use the slanted supports that they match up in some flowing way, so that they don't overlap like you have some of them. Use real water instead of the scenery (it was understandable in Hell's Cross, but try to get away from it) and use more trees. It was barren tundra, but with mountans
Edited by Ling, 05 June 2007 - 02:59 PM.
Vekoma9- i think it was really the design of the coaster that got you this. the other looked but and unique. the landscaping was nice. in places alittle confused looking. the archy was good in places but blocky in others. you had some nice details and some places that lacked. at times it looked incomplete. nice work overall, especially the coaster
Lucas92- i liked the archy better in your entry. nice and detailed and fit well. the landscaping in yours was great as well but your coaster feel through. it was short, and took time to go around only because it was slow. i didnt like the second(sorta) chainhill thing you had going on. some of the tunrs and hills were nice but i didnt like the overall flow.
Coasteranne-this entry just didnt do much for me. the layout was okay, not bad, but not great. the detail was there in your archy just it was hard to distingish. alot of your park was paths that surrounded the coaster that led from nowhere and to no where. i thought it had too much forest when you could have spread out the detail.
Xin-the layout on this was very big, but didnt realy need to be. the idea of stopping under the waterfall was cool, but kinda hard to see through the arches. the archy was better but there wasnt much and it was still pretty blocky. the foliage was very much alot of the same. the landscape was flat, bare at times, and all the same. maybe next time try taking your time in a small area instead of doing not much in alot of area.
congrats vekoma9 and Ling!!
FK+Coastermind
Edited by FK+Coastermind, 05 June 2007 - 03:43 PM.
FullMetal Offline
Downloading the entries now. Will post comments in a couple of hours (damn dial-up).
Edited by Xin, 05 June 2007 - 08:04 PM.
C:/Program Files/Hasbro Ineractive/RollerCoaster Tycoon/Saved Games
I don't understand that....because I mistakenly thought this round was the best wooden coaster
I think he had the second best layout, but nice entry, good job!
I fail to see how this entry was boring....my goodness, the clear winner to me. Excellent job.
Exactly.
Yeah....the coaster layout was imo just horrid...not that I'm a connoisseur of coasters
Nice job also to CoasterAnne, Lucas, and Xin.
In short, Panic deserves to be in the Pro Tour.
FullMetal Offline
RCT2 Entries
CoasterAnne - Nice layout IMO. I liked it, and I think that if you picked out a couple more colors for the buildings, you couldv'e placed much better.
Lucas92 - Great entry! I loved the station building, and thought it fit really well with the rest of the ride. What I didn't like were the yellow arches on the coaster track itself. Otherwise, I think you did great.
Vekoma9 - Awesome! In your comment about my coaster, you said I should've spent more time on it, yet you spent 2 days on yours and got first place. That's an achievment all by itself. Anyway, loved every bit of it. Just don't spend 2 days on your finals every, k?
LL Entries
Panic - Definately the best layout, hands down. It's impossible to even think about debating that. Could have used a bit more in terms of archy to make it more interesting, but definately a winner in my book.
Ling - Wow. You defenitely know how to make a great themed coaster. But all those chainlifts made it seem kind of weird. Otherwise, good entry.
BTW, thanks Ling for assisting me in opening the LL files. I had to download the Drexler patch to open them though. Now I can start downloading LL spotlight parks!