Park / Land of Wonders

Which park is better?

  1. Land of Wonders - Whzz Kids 29 votes [72.50%]
    Percentage of vote: 72.50%
  2. Vampyre - Flying Germans 11 votes [27.50%]
    Percentage of vote: 27.50%

147 Comments

This park shares comments with 1 other park(View Park)
  • posix%s's Photo

    Round Robin
    Annotations
    • The poll will stay open for exactly 120 hours.
    • You can only vote by entering BOTH vote codes you find in the custom message of the parks.
    • If you are a member of a team that is in this match up, you can not vote and will automatically see the poll outcome.
    • You will only receive a vote code if you are logged in with a forum account.
    • Only members registered before 3/11/09 will be able to vote.
    Round 1 | Match 2

    Whzz Kids
    "Land of Wonders"
    (RCT2)
    VS
    Flying Germans
    "Vampyre"
    (RCT2)

    Match Decision
    The 120 hours voting time for this poll have passed. Here are the official results of the match.
    <
    "Vampyre"
    11
    27.50%
    Park
    Votes
    Vote %
    Creators
    "Land of Wonders"
    29
    72.50%
  • Levis%s's Photo
    seems to me this is going to be pretty obvious.
    will download the parks tomorrow and comment on them
  • Six Frags%s's Photo
    Yep, unfortunately this is pretty easy.. Shame the Flying Germans park is unfinished; If it was finished I think it could beat land of wonders, because what was there was very nice.. Loved the invert and the architecture throughout.. Land of Wonders just was more fun to look at; Loved the peepfriendlyness, rides and atmosphere.. Only downside for me was the custom scenery roofs by cjk.. I always thought they looked un-rctish and non-aesthetically.. I thought the left corner was kinda unfinished too and there was quite a few water, but you guys hid it more, so in the end I voted for an overall more appealing and entertaining park..

    I know the best is saved for last, so looking forward to the final match-up for round 1! :p

    SF
  • Comet%s's Photo
    Wow, if Vampyre was finished even with only the one coaster it would have been a surprisingly difficult decision.
    Everything finished was amazing and done perfectly. I loved how clean all the buildings, supports, and foliage were. I've never seen that theme done so well.
    So good job to whoever worked on it and too bad about not finishing it, you were on to something really good.

    I'll write more about Land of Wonders when I look into it more in depth, I'm pretty sure that's where my votes going though.
  • Brent%s's Photo
    Nice one Germans...
  • Dr_Dude%s's Photo
    It's a shame about the hard drive crash, but I don't suspect I would have voted Germans anyway. LoW was a very, very fun park and although it left something to be desired I enjoyed it much more than I can see my self enjoying a finished Vampyre. While the architecture and coaster obviously took time and effort I found everything rather dull.
  • Nokia%s's Photo
    i hate these fucking codes.

    anyways if i could get my codes to work i would vote for the flying germans park.
    it was very very nice and would be 10x better if finshed but its still nice none the less, and as comet said everything was pulled off perfectly.

    i didn't really like whzz kid's entry. i felt like some buildings were just rushed, and were missing some details that other buildings had. some of the coasters were a little weird too.

    edit:nvm i fixed my codes ;)

    Edited by Nokia, 20 April 2009 - 07:11 PM.

  • Gwazi%s's Photo
    Lands of Wonder:
    this was one hell of a park. i am usually not a fan of this type of realism, but the architecture was well-done and there were so many little things to look at. it was a very polished park, with some pretty fun rides and very good foliage/landscaping. there wasn't too much wrong with it, to be honest.

    Vampyre:
    i'm usually a strong critic of unfinished parks in contests. last H2H i quit voting because i got so frustrated with the unfinishedness of everything. however, i have also had a hard-drive failure before, and i understand how much of a bitch it is. because of that, i did not penalize the Flying Germans for the park being unfinished.

    the park is stunningly good, despite not being done. the architecture is absolutely perfect, and it really adds to the atmosphere. thats the strongest point of this park. the atmosphere. it oozes atmosphere. as i said in the topic "how do you?" atmosphere is my #1 priority in a park. this park delivers. i felt like i was there, the theme was done so well. because of this, as well as the fact that its pretty obvious the Flying Germans won't win anyway (that's very unfortunate that the park had to be sent in unfinished, as this would be a very good match-up otherwise), is why i voted for this park over Land of Wonders.
  • Kumba%s's Photo
    Voted for the team im calling by the name they almost had I picked that was way cooler. I voted G-Unit :p

    The parks name sucked ass (funny ours did too, well the pot is calling the kettle black...), but other then that it was pretty nice, nothing amazing, but a good peep friendly park. I liked the yellow coaster best, the other two were okay. 7/10

    Flying Germans im sorry to hear what to your park, but I just cant bring myself to vote for an unfinished park like this despide your reasons or potential which you had. If it was finished and had a couple more rides you might have made this close. 5.5/10
  • chapelz%s's Photo
    Had the Germans not had problems it would have been no contest as it is I am having a hard time deciding.
  • Ride6%s's Photo

    Had the Germans not had problems it would have been no contest as it is I am having a hard time deciding.


    That's pretty much where I'm at. All the coasters in Land of Wonders were cop-outs in some way or another and other than being well constructed and 'pretty' it didn't have anything else going for it. The first half of the yellow one's layout was unholy awesome, but once it touched the MCBR the party was OVER. Thor was good other than the half-assed top hat... How hard is it to do a couple track merges guys? You did it for the loop didn't you!? I might understand if it was the really short variation on the top hat, but it was not... The woody just wondered about aimlessly... With some good air at least, but it didn't feel like much thought went towards the layout... Rockets was probably my favorite just because the block sections were timed perfectly and the queue was sweet.

    Vampyre, while far from having the perfect coaster also had an ominous atmosphere that would've been amazingly impressive had it been completed. Oh well...

    I voted for the one I believe will lose because they don't deserve the vote margin they're going to get...

    Ride6

    EDIT: my apologies on the top hat misunderstanding. Thor is quite a good coaster... *shrugs*
  • Comet%s's Photo
    ^The top hat and whole coaster is supposed to be like Blue Fire at Europa Park, that was by far the highlight for me.

    Edit: I'm assuming, at least.
    Blue Fire

    Edited by Comet, 20 April 2009 - 09:13 PM.

  • geewhzz%s's Photo
    Uh, Ride6, obviously you have no idea what you're talking about. Thor is not a 'cop out' and actually has a great layout with great pacing based off of the new Mack LSM @ Europa Park.

    Guys, don't believe everything you read. The readme does not tell the entire story. This park was never 'finished'. So no, they don't get any sympathy from me and are lucky they're going to get any votes out of this.
  • RRP%s's Photo
    I agree that thor wasnt a 'cop out',i thought it was a great ride based from blue fire and the highlight of the park alng with the pier area.I tought that was very well done.The other coaster were ok,nothing outstanding though
  • Milo%s's Photo
    shame, could have been a great round....

    Land of Wonders
    Pros-pretty obvious who had a part in this imo and it's about what I'd expect. A very fun park to look around. There are plenty of rides to take in which is great although I didn't much care for the woodie, it felt a little smashed. I think some of that bare corner, which actually added some nice contrast to the busy center, would have been better used for a cleaner layout. Thor was easily the best coaster and the looper (name escapes me) was nice. It's tough for me to really get into compact coasters but the surroundings worked hard enough to make them fun to watch, as well as the interaction. There was plenty of eye candy as well, the go-kart station, the path covers and the tan wall on the waterfront were all awesome details. The flats and mini coasters were integrated well into the architecture. Seeing things like the bumper cars in that building and the BBQ in the picnic area put a smile on my face.
    Cons- with all the rides it got a little chaotic looking through this at times. The bare corner and the water kind of stuck out. As I said before, they added a small amount of harmony to the park but also left some balance in the layout to be desired. It was also almost too sterile in a way, it's hard to explain but the peeps really saved this park atmosphere wise... which is what the style is imo... peepable semi realism.

    Vampyre
    Pros- Well if this would have been finished it probably would have got my vote but as is it is little more than a mini full of potential. The coaster was pretty cool and I loved all the tunnels through holes in the walls and open gates. It's kind of a polar opposite to the Kid's park as instead of several small layouts there is one dominating coaster. I appreciated the attention to a particular theme and that would have been a major selling point vs Lands of Wonder. The architecture there was great, particularly the attention to the outer walls and gates and little extras like the outer paths.
    Cons- unfinishedness obviously, and I'm not sure if it was supposed to be peepable or not.... if not it would have been a tougher choice had this been finished

    pretty obvious which team got my vote. Shame about the lack of a finished park HD crash or not...
  • Katapultable%s's Photo
    Haven't donwloaded yet, so my opinion will come later.

    I think, in a few months, we're going to see Vampyre win an NE design.
  • Micool%s's Photo
    You can all see why we expected to win round one...
  • Magnus%s's Photo
    The clear things up a little:

    The park was supposed to get finished the day before the deadline by [insert player name]. Due to technical problems (hard disk failiure) he had no chance to work on the park and apart from a short message had no chance to communicate with the team.
    The park could have been finished in a day certainly as most of it is finishing the castle (which was completely planned out) add in foliage and shops. (The park was supposed to be peepable.)

    We are very sorry for the unfinishedness of the park as that is not what it was supposed to be. Thanks to the team of gee we were allowed to send it the unfinished version of the park (on which no work was done after the day before the deadline) late. Thanks again for that.


    Also major thanks to the second player working on the park. Some really good work from you and you adapted very well to the style of your partner.
  • posix%s's Photo
    honestly, i very much doubt the park could have been finished in that last day. maybe it's just me, but finishing something takes much more time than you usually think. at least to my experience. even if the majority of the park is done, what's left are all those little areas you didn't like and therefore let empty. now that you're going to have to finish them it can be quite hard.

    however, almost like anyone else, had vampyre been finished, i could have see myself vote for it. land of wonders was busy and kinda fun, but i also found it was confusing and disordered. i didn't really care for any of the rides, but some of the park design itself (mainly entrance area) had something going for it. overall it just did more than vampyre. so i voted whzz kids.
  • Magnus%s's Photo
    I know it can be done. At least I did something similar twice in H2H so far. Just look at Isla Magica, that was done in 5 building days, including the custom fence base object.
    But that is not what we want to discuss here I think.



    If our park was finished I could see it winning, but am not sure about it, because of the realism trend we are seeing at NE at the moment. I think the Whzz Kids Park goes exactly for that trend, but the park did not do much for me. The theming is too sterile and all in all it was too confusing to look at for me.

    But since I cannot vote, which is good, because I really do not want to tell my team to vote for an unfinished park, my opinion does not matter anyways.


    Magnus