FYI myself and Xcoaster did work on hour entires today, which is after the deadline. This is not worth a DQ, but I think it might be fair to dock votes. I would lose 1 coz I took about an hour off the clock and Ryan would lose 3.
Ride6 and Cam I will leave it up to you guys since you got your entries in on time.
And for those who are wondering where it is the voting poll will be added in 24 hours. Id like people to DL all 4, look at them and think before they vote
Would a tiebreaker loss be fair for you guys if it came to that?
Still what I think should happen. Although its technically the same as -1 vote I guess, its more important in terms of ranking. Because if its late and not going to get dqed, its still the same quality and still deserves the votes it gets. But if its a tie, meaning that the entries are exact same quality theoritically, the one finished within the deadline with less time to work should get the higher place. Not sure if I explained it very clearly but thats my opinion on that.
And for those who are wondering where it is the voting poll will be added in 24 hours. Id like people to DL all 4, look at them and think before they vote
It has come up a few times, but for MM these 4 benches are the only you can use scenery from. Using scenery that is not on one of these benches will result in a penalty, and could result in a DQ.
I know the maker of Rosetta did not mean to add anything, so I hope that 4th "peep" bench does the trick.
I think I'll go with the Beatles as well. As much as I liked Rosetta Stone, the Star Flyer and tons of references with the Beatles makes me give that one the nod.
I think all the entries are fairly even. IMO Glass Castle heights is the weakest, but has the best coaster of the final round in Iron Butterfly. The rest of it is very 'meh'. Adrenaline Estates is exacted pretty well and seems like a new idea tho Butterfinger did it better in his PT1 entry. I really like what the parkmaker did, but in the end I found it to sloppy to consider giving it a vote over the front runners.
I think this will come down to The Beatles vs. The Rosetta Sphere. It should be really close. I feel that the Beatles is the more fun entry and I really like all the details from Beatles songs. The parkmaker pulled everything off very well and created a great micro world. The only knock on it IMO is that the ideas were already out there and all the maker had to do was adapt to them and it is really a spoof park, but I still like it a lot. On the other hand you have Rosetta. The sphere itself is pretty cool as a focal point and the two main rides are pulled off well. It is also a very peep friendly park and has some of the most guests of any MM entry. My vote will go to Rosetta because I think it is clear that the most work went into it and overall it was the most soild entry.
Anywayz, I'm still deciding if I should go for Rosetta or The Beatles.. Atm I'm leaning towards the Beatles park, because, like CP6 said, of all the Beatles references, execution (of the concept), atmosphere and overall quality of the park..
I will go back and forth a few times before I decide where my vote is going
52 Comments
Kumba Offline
The Championship
Xcoaster vs. Kumba vs. Ride6 vs. Camcorder22
Adrenaline Estates
The Beatles
Glass Castle Heights
The Rosetta Sphere
JJ Offline
Kumba Offline
Ride6 and Cam I will leave it up to you guys since you got your entries in on time.
And for those who are wondering where it is the voting poll will be added in 24 hours. Id like people to DL all 4, look at them and think before they vote
Camcorder22 Offline
Still what I think should happen. Although its technically the same as -1 vote I guess, its more important in terms of ranking. Because if its late and not going to get dqed, its still the same quality and still deserves the votes it gets. But if its a tie, meaning that the entries are exact same quality theoritically, the one finished within the deadline with less time to work should get the higher place. Not sure if I explained it very clearly but thats my opinion on that.
JJ Offline
I just thought you were making us post
RCTNW Offline
disneylhand Offline
Let the best park win.
(Though what Camcorder said is good too, regarding a tie)
-disneylhand
Steve Offline
Corkscrew Offline
chapelz Offline
lucas92 Offline
trav Offline
Sulakke Offline
Kumba Offline
Well there are 4 legal benches
I know the maker of Rosetta did not mean to add anything, so I hope that 4th "peep" bench does the trick.
RCTNW Offline
Liampie Offline
CedarPoint6 Offline
Kumba Offline
I think this will come down to The Beatles vs. The Rosetta Sphere. It should be really close. I feel that the Beatles is the more fun entry and I really like all the details from Beatles songs. The parkmaker pulled everything off very well and created a great micro world. The only knock on it IMO is that the ideas were already out there and all the maker had to do was adapt to them and it is really a spoof park, but I still like it a lot. On the other hand you have Rosetta. The sphere itself is pretty cool as a focal point and the two main rides are pulled off well. It is also a very peep friendly park and has some of the most guests of any MM entry. My vote will go to Rosetta because I think it is clear that the most work went into it and overall it was the most soild entry.
Six Frags Offline
I will go back and forth a few times before I decide where my vote is going
SF
Comet Offline
Oh, and just for the homepage article Kumba, Camcorder never beat RCTNW...