Park / [H2H6] R3 - Flying Germans - The Adventures of Harry Potter

92 Comments

This park shares comments with 1 other park(View Park)
  • Ruben%s's Photo

    Honestly this is just bull shit and you know it.


    You so cool. You must've attended cool-school. Really.




    So.... on to things that dó matter, being things that aren't rct2isboss:

    Germans:

    It's always sad to see H2H-parks unfinished, and it must've been a real bummer for the builders that have put their time and effort in this. I really hope to see you guys finish this after H2H because it still has a lot of potential. For now:

    + I like the duelling coasters, very enjoyable layouts and smart choice of theme.
    + There were some really cool details in this, like the chess set and the motorbike. Small things that point towards the movie but really add. Can imagine you were planning to put a lot more of this in the park.

    - Multiple things felt really out of place. The backstage/office area just didn't suit the rest of the park. Also, rides like the first year boats/aragog felt like you just hád to place them on the map even if they didn't fit in there. Aragog in the middle of a city just doesn't work as a concept, and the first year boats in such a unmisterious setting landing close to loads of pavement and buildings just doesn't do the whole idea of them justice.
    - General unfinishedness, but you already knew that.



    Canes:
    First of all: I didn't like the movie. Second: I liked the park. You guys did some really cool stuff in here, I liked certain bits more than others, but overall this park was a joy to watch:

    + Really liked all the vehicles, nice recreations of one of the only cool features in the actual movie.
    + The training course was cool, and in fact the entire base was very well put together. Nicely detailed, the right atmosphere etc.
    + Loved the staff names, there's a lot of fun in there on several levels. From famous people to complete randomness and everything in between. I liked it a lot.
    + I really enjoyed the second half of the B&M, nice layout and speed. The first half was okay, but the second half just stood out for me.

    - The forest area felt rather overhacked/-complicated. It's probably just a difference in style, but all the lag and glitching took more away from the atmosphere than the hacks/scenery used added to it. I know some people don't mind this as much as I do, but it kinda undid the brilliance (which it reallly had, in a sense) that was so carefully created.

    P.s. the dancing with wolves joke is brilliant. Just brilliant.

    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes


    P.P.S. builders of both parks put hours of work in this, maybe put some work in voting as a thank you as well? I really miss critical/detailed reviews in this topic, which is a shame. Not questioning people's votes, but some more willingness to give feedback will probably be appreciated by the builders involved. ;)
  • Ver-co%s's Photo
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes
  • AvanineCommuter%s's Photo
    Flying Germans:

    Besides a few faults and the glaring unfinishedness of it, I rather enjoyed the park.

    My absolute favorite part has to be the whomping willow, it was superbly executed, innovative, and extremely creative; I haven't seen a flat ride excite me this much!

    While the layout for the duelers was well made, it is really cliché to have a dueling dragons type ride in a Harry Potter park... can you say "been there, done that"? Would have liked to see a more innovative approach to Harry Potter.

    The architecture of Hogsmead was disappointing, as it didn't really have the 'village' feel since it used the same roof/walls as Hogwarts itself (this doesn't make ANY sense, how can a castle and a village have the SAME materials???).

    The chamber of secrets was a very cool ride, and I did like the layout of the park.

    Hurricanes:

    Loved the Banshee ride, very creative and again very well executed.

    The floating islands themselves were impressive, but I REALLY DISLIKE the clouds around them. It ups the mess factor in the park x10.

    The first part of the main coaster was atrocious. The second part was FANTASTIC. Overall the coaster becomes mediocre.

    I love the giant tree, it was superbly done. The gardens around it could have used more foilage, but the overall feel was great.

    The Army base was fantastic as well, there were so many little details from the film that were captured in the interiors. The recreations of the planes and tanks left me thinking "wow..." Best part of the park.

    Definitely should have named the park something more creative than "Avatar", and the welcome message should have been "Welcome to Pandora". But that's just my opinion.


    Could've been a great matchup, but unfortunately the Germans' park was too unfinished. No contest:
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes
  • nin%s's Photo
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes

    Avatar was good, but like others have said it seemed a bit messy in places, though that didn't take away too much. The flyer was pretty original and there were plenty of neat details all over.

    Harry Potter could have been excellent, but was simply too unfinished to even be considered for a vote. I hope this can either be finished afterward or be redone and made to a high standard.
  • Turtle%s's Photo
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes

    Harry Potter -

    Great layout for the coasters, for the first 80% of them. The endings were a little off, which was a shame. But awesome speed at the start, loved it. Really good to see some nice duelers.

    This park had a lot of potential, just obviously you lost love for the project as a team. Some parts were absolutely fantastic... Hagrid's hut was brilliant, really great feel for that. I knew immediately what it was. Some of the architecture had flashes of brilliance, but Hogsmeade would have been much better with less steep rooves, in my opinion. I kinda know what you were going for, but these are too steep for me.

    The office building, while very nice, left me thinking "why?!". Maybe in a more finished park it wouldn't have stood out as much and would have been a nice addition.

    Overall, pity it wasn't finished.

    Avatar -

    Well I guessed two of the three builders immediately (although you didn't have to put them in a cave... slightly risky I thought!). This was undoubtably a good park, and i'm glad to finally see a good Avatar park, but I can never love this just because it's so damn messy.

    So many little flashes of brilliance all through the park, clever details, wonderful building. Just to name a few - the ornithopter, pandora hologram, vehicles in the army base, bulldozer, in fact, most of the army base. Lovely work, and it didn't feel sterile at all, which was really well done. The Avatar training ride, I actually have NO idea how you hacked that. Cool.

    The floating islands kinda HAD to be included, and yet they really messed this park up I thought. The mist ruined the view of everything, and the islands messed up many views of things. One of those "nice idea, bad aesthetics" things. Same goes for a lot of things in this park. Nice try at the giant tree, I know first hand how hard it is to build one of those. The foliage throughout the park was the major drawback I think. It's almost the defining feature of Pandora, and it could have been done so much better than just recolouring some jungle trees.

    The coaster and surrounding areas felt like a theme park in places, which confused me. Sort of not knowing how to build this park, as a theme park or a recreation, which is understandable as i've had the same problem quite a few times. Especially difficult with a movie park.

    Overall, enough brilliance throughout to carry what aesthetically didn't really work for me. I'm sure this would have gotten my vote over many a park this season, but I don't love it yet. Still, definitely commendable to finish a park of this scope and size to this level of detail in such a time frame. Nice work guys.
  • hulkpower25%s's Photo
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes
  • pierrot%s's Photo
    Posted Image

    I'm wondering who did a waterfall area. It just looks incredibly aesthetic, great execution with brilliant interaction.
    Certainly best landscaping so far in H2H6.
  • 5dave%s's Photo
    Avatar:
    This park was pretty much all you could ask for an Avatar themed park. But I felt it couldn't decide if it was a real theme park or a fantasy park. On one hand you had a more or less realistic ride layout, a few believable rides and down-to-earth architecture, on the other hand you had these flying islands, the animals flying around and no real hint if it was a park or the Avatar world itself. I just wished you'd have decided for either. But don't get me wrong - the ideas were really great. I loved the base area with all the indoor and underground details, the scenes you know from the movie and also I got the feeling from the movie too which was really great! The ride ideas were great - the seeds of the tree and the ride on that big creature as a main ride seemed logical to me and well executed. What I also didn't like were the slight messiness of the park and those tree trunk objects, they somehow stood out so much. I can't really say much more about the park. The jungle could have used a little more color - it seemed much more colorful and whimsical in the movie. If the park decided if it was a theme park or a fantasy approach it would have been much more amazing.

    Harry Potter:
    Kudos for the theme of the park. Seemed to be due for long enough. Even I toyed with the theme already! The park layout looked nice. The sign to the area was nice but I think the scar symbol would have been better than the glasses. The owl ride was a nice idea and I can imagine it being built in a real Harry potter area. The architecture was pretty much based on the real area it seems and it was quite nice, although not as atmospheric as in RL. I didn't really get the pumpkin ride there, I couldn't recall a pumpkin playing a major role in the books/movies to justify a ride in an Harry Potter area. Hagrid's hut was perfect and so was the wheeping willow ride. I just hoped everything was finished. I didn't really get the blue/purple tent at the end of the Hogsmeade area. Was it from goblet of fire? The ferris wheel looked lackluster and I wonder what the wlakthrough house(?) was for, I couldn't really tell what was going on there. Also the Hogwarts express would have been cooler if it would lead from Hogsmeade to the Castle or something. It didn't make much sense as it was. The castle itself and the ride could have turned out so cool if it was finished, although the structure was really damn big. I didn't get why you finished those office buildings outside the park rather than the park itself. Might be were one builder stopped working and the other just didn't have time. For the layouts of the coasters: The start was nice, the loops and corkscrews awkward, the pacing too fast in some parts (you used trimbrakes too it seems), the endings weren't in synch (would have been cooler if both the trains hit the brake nearly at the same time) and the missing BBS was dissapointing too. Please work on that - the interactions with the castle give the opportunity for an awesome ride! All in all it was a promising park but so dissapointing everything was unfinished. I just hope the Flying Germans will pick up the pace already and show their full potential. I know they can do it! We want to beat Robbie in the finals! :p

    All in all a matchup that could have been amazing, but since I can't vote on parks that could have been rather than on parks that are:

    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes
  • turbin3%s's Photo
    As far as I know the walkthrough house was supposed to be a house like in Toverland, where you can point at special infrarot sensors with magic wands and things are moving then.
  • Insanity%s's Photo
    I vote Hurrianes.
  • CedarPoint6%s's Photo
    Posted ImageI vote Hurricanes

    Wish I could have seen Potter finished because what was there was really great. But regardless of that Avatar looked great. I was a big fan of the military complex especially-- that was well put together and the realistic details were nice, especially the aircraft. The realist in me wasn't a huge fan of the coaster, but I loved the way it looked and it was fun to watch. I was less of a fan of the floating stuff and things flying around, but it does certainly fit the theme. Really this was just a fun park to look around in general-- there was a lot going on.
  • posix%s's Photo

    Voting Closed
    Hurricanes beat Flying Germans



    Avatar was made by wheres_walto, Levis and In:Cities. The Adventures of Harry Potter was made by turbin3 and disneylhand.



    Hurricanes vote count: 32
    Voters: BC(rct2), Wanted, trav, StormRunnerFan, rct2isboss, RCTMASTA, FK+Coastermind, tyandor, MorganFan, RCTER2, Shotguns?, Cocoa, Roomie, Miracle, Arjan v l, pierrot, Ling, MCI, Dr_Dude, CoasterCreator9, ivo, Pacificoaster, Xtreme97, ScOtLaNdS_FiNeSt, Ruben, Ver-co, AvanineCommuter, nin, Turtle, hulkpower25, 5dave, CedarPoint6

    Flying Germans vote count: 1
    Voters: 111112oo

  • Six Frags%s's Photo

    Flying Germans vote count: 1
    Voters: 111112oo


    You have some explaining to do, "111112oo"
  • Kumba%s's Photo
    Great work by our guys on this, I knew from early on when Walto posted that this might just be our strongest park of the season and imo it's clearly in the top 3 of all H2H6 parks released so far. Walto has serious talent, he was a steal in what is actually the same draft slot where I got robbie last season ;)

    Levis was a natural to help with this, I loved the hacks he did and this was one of the rare parks where they could truly work for the best. Josh... he just wants to build on everything and as of now is our team MVP :p

    I only feel bad that our guys need to live with the fact that a lot of you thought I was one of the builders :kumbasgreen:
  • wheres_walto%s's Photo
    Thanks for the comments everyone. This park for the first month or so was solo work by me due to other commitments. As far as who did what cause I know somebody asked:

    Levis:
    Home Tree
    Flight of the Banshee
    Bioluminescent foliage
    Hallelujah mountains

    In:Cities:
    Most of the architecture in the military base
    Most of the vehicles in the base

    wheres_walto:
    Toruk Makto
    Trials of Eywa
    The cliff/waterfalls and forest
    Tsaheylu
    Basketball courts and link trailers
    Helicopters and biosuits
    Staff naming
  • In:Cities%s's Photo
    Really had a blast working on this. Although I wish I would have had more time to contribute.

    Thank you all for the kind feedback!
  • turbin3%s's Photo
    Posted Image
  • Cocoa%s's Photo
    I knew walto was on this because he had posted pics of a different avatar project in the AD a little while back. and incities, that is some amazing work you did! the military base is so different than your style, I was sure it was kumba or something... kudos on that, it really made the park for me (apart from, well, everything else :p)
  • BelgianGuy%s's Photo
    Josh, you've really cracked your glass ceiling, your skill in terms of aesthetics and executing an idea has gone up SOOOO much in the short period of h2h6, I really look forward to seeing another solo from you, only thing I hope you'll showcase then is good layout because in this h2h it seems as if you've stayed away from that aspect of parkmaking...

    Walto is a serious up and comming player and I really hope to see more from you aswell

    Levis needs no introduction in terms of style and skill so it's just waiting for him to build really



    but still I can't stress enough how badly I would like to see harry potter finished though, the bits that are there are great and it'd be a shame if this never got finished
  • In:Cities%s's Photo
    Thank you so much for the kind words. However, Walt is truly the greatest superstar here! This park was his vision, and he did the vast majority of the work.
    Don't worry though, you've only seen a little bit of me so far!;]