Park / Mine Mania
-
12-May 08
- Views 892,137
- Downloads 619
- Fans 1
- Comments 1,093
-
1 fan Fans of this park
-
Full-Size Map
-
Download Park
619
-
Objects
117
-
Tags
I guess not, but...
Good News: I don't plan on ever being the main judge again after this, it's just to hard. Polls might be the way to go next time.
Bad News: You keep hating on me for knocking IC down a notch on some peoples lists
Not always true. I really didn't expect Ling to come out with what he did. The judge shouldn't even know who sent in entries. The entries should be sent to someone else and then that person sends all the entries to Kumba anonymously. That's just my idea though, maybe its too elaborate.
Fuck.
Edit- Good post Panic. Not really my style but an interesting take on rct you don't see too often any more. Which is a damn shame.
And I can see you're logic on this Kumba, but I still don't agree with it at all.
In my opinion a "team of experts" judging setup would be optimal, but its practicality is another matter.
Better yet I won't be one of them as I intend on winning my money back
That doesn't mean anything to those of us who now have zero shot of making it to the finals if you use polls. Please Kumba... no polls.
So please do not enter the B&M round because I'd love to see you AND one of these guys in the finals!
Even if you won't enter the B&M round, it will be the hardest and the round with the most participants!
So good luck everyone and at first I wanted to enter the B&M round, too but I think my solo is more important for me than this solo thing.
Oh and the B&M round is looking really good
Really, none of the other layouts were over-the-top amazing, but panic's was certainly clean and crisp. It was really nostaligic reminding me of the woody in Moonlight Magic, i think it was called Timberwolf. Sure it had nice landscaping, but the architecture didn't seem to match the skill enough to really pull off the job entirely (though i don't agree with that there should be more architecture, architecture needs to serve a point.
The flowers were nice, the grey landsides have been missing for ages (due to rct1 missing for ages, i'm sure). That's what definitely made this a winner for me.
And apart from that, the other entries could not keep my interest at all. Though panic's entry wasn't that much to look at either. It's really near perfection, but it really has too little of anything to amaze me. One good layout, not one-of-a-kind special, and some classic landscaping that we've all seen before too. But i've seen the attempts at good aestetics that don't work, way, way more often than aestetics that do work so i can still come to the same conclusion on that panic maybe should have win. I could have told you beforehand Kumba wouldn't pick it though.
And Kumba, stop saying stupid stuff like how your 110% is made up, especially when you take account on who made the park. That has nothing to do with it, and even if it does subconciously lie about it. Get it? A single i thought the woody Ling made was better than Panic's, and i judged this round, would have sufficed. Much less argument would have followed.
And the judging, i've offered my help here. I'm sure one of Corkscewed/Posix/Ed/Turtle/etc. could help out (I see Turtle and Posix posting here, so they're looking at these entries..). Have 3-4 judges, if the vote is tied make up a decision and no one will bitch about it because various people came to the conclusion. If they attack the vote, all three or four of the judges will be able to defend the decision too, so you'll never be alone in what you think! (or, practically never) Though i think some of these other entries were judged that way, so just go down that same route.
I wish I didn't lose my entry... Then I'd be able to enter the B&M round...
Looking forward to the round!
If you enter a Pre-Lim with LL and win. Does that mean you have to do the Finals in LL too? Or can you do that in RCT2?
Hehe. I'm stupid but it has to be asked.
Yep.