conkerlfc

• Offline
• United Kingdom

Yeah, I get that, but you can't deny it detracts from screens that people have actually put time and effort into.

give him real criticism and until you do you need to sit the fuck down.

I have seen this mentioned a few times, could you actually define what real criticism is? Is 'not covering the map with trees and not having like 7 coasters in the same screen' valid criticism, which he has so far not been able to take on board. 

historyfreak's screens genuinely have more content that a lot of "acceptable" screens on this site. its messy content, I think once or twice it's been pre-fab content, but its still a lot. i really don't see the difference between one of his screens and a screen thats like two buildings, 1/18 of a layout and some three-wide path.

Yeah, the screen may be filled, but it takes no skill or creativity whatsoever,. Literally anybody could post any of the screens he has posted and could do it in like 10/15 minutes. It takes time and effort to create buildings, yeah they might not be the best buildings, but at least they've tried, and most other people take criticism on board and improve. 

It could be classed as spam though, a lot of people don't like the screenshots judging by the comments. I edited it because I wanted to delete the thread. I didn't think my post was particularly insulting to anyone or anything, and I think I put some good points forward, but I just couldn't be bothered with it.

you could say if the average after 5-10 votes on the screen is below 30 percent then it either doesn't get bumped any more or is just taken off the site permanently.

I think that's actually a good suggestion, if it could be implemented. 

Yeah I would have least filled the open area after you pulled it out of the server. I really like the rest though, really good stuff. 

I think this is an improvement over your other screens. Still a little bit cluttered, keep taking on feedback and you will improve